Sourcemaps pointing to wrong file

[JParkinson1991]

• Operating System: macOS 10.14.5
• Node Version: 8.16.0
• NPM Version: 6.4.1
• webpack Version: 4.35.0
• sass-loader Version: 7.1.0

It seems that there (somewhere in the chain) are some alterations to node-sass generated sourcemaps which results in them pointing to the wrong scss source declarations.

The sourcemaps do not point to completely the wrong file, the point to a file/line in which styling exists for the element, just not the file/line where the shown styles have been defined.

Assumptions

• When style definitions exist in multiple files, sourcemaps point to one of (but in some cases) the wrong file in which they are defined.
• This only seems to be the case when multiple style definitions exist for an element

Screenshots

Webpack generated sourcemap - broken - chrome browser

node-sass generated sourcemap - working - chrome browser

How Do We Reproduce?

Reproducable repository here:
https://github.com/JParkinson1991/webpack-sourcemaps-debug

The ./public/index.html page in the above repository will show the expected locations of sourcemap references.

These expected locations are correct when the sourcemaps are generated/styles compiled with node-sass directly. This can be achieved by running the following in the above repository npm run script build:node-sass

However, when compiled using webpack and usings its generated sourcemaps the locations do not match up, they are not compeltely wrong in that they reference somewhere in source where this file has been generated, but not the correct point in the code.
Can be checked by running the following in the above repository npm run script build:webpack

Testing

In chrome, when source compiled with node-sass the sourcemaps are correct, they are incorrect when compiled with webpack.

In firefox, sourcemaps are incorrect when source compiled with both webpack and node-sass

---

If you need anymore information on this one, let me know.
Thanks in advance for any help/input provided on this one!

[JParkinson1991]

Just to note, as seen in someother issues setting sass-load outputStyle to compressed seems to make things worse.

{
    loader: 'sass-loader',
    options: {
        sourceMap: true,
        outputStyle: 'compressed'
    }
}

See how the sourcemaps now point to the files containing the mixin in the actual style definition.

@file _navbar.scss

.navbar {
  position: relative;
  min-height: $navbar-height; // Ensure a navbar always shows (e.g., without a .navbar-brand in collapsed mode)
  margin-bottom: $navbar-margin-bottom;
  border: 1px solid transparent;

  // Prevent floats from breaking the navbar
  @include clearfix; // !!! -> THIS IS WHAT LIVES IN _clearfix.scss

  @media (min-width: $grid-float-breakpoint) {
    border-radius: $navbar-border-radius;
  }
}

[JParkinson1991]

In all of the above examples .navbar-default points to the correct part of the code in the soucemap.

There is only one style block/definition for .navbar-default in all of the @imported bootstrap-sass source files.

Im starting to believe this issue stems from element styles being defined in multiples.

This doesn't answer the question on why compressed shows the mixin definition file however.

[alexander-akait]

In firefox, sourcemaps are incorrect when source compiled with both webpack and node-sass

Problem in firefox (known issue)

To be honestly we don't modify source maps from node-sass, so problem in postcss-loader or in your minificator

[JParkinson1991]

If you look at the repository i posted there is no post css or minification that takes place when producing these errors.

Sass-loader is passed to css-loader then onto mini css extract plugin.

[alexander-akait]

Looks problem in css-loader/ MCEP, i will looks on this in near future, reproducible test repo is enouth, thanks

[JParkinson1991]

Great! I don’t know where to start with debugging this but if theres anything i can do to help just let me know!

[alexander-akait]

switching on sass (dart-sass) solves problem too, continue investigation

[alexander-akait]

Yep, bug on node-sass side, you can put code:

require('fs').writeFileSync('./style.css', result.css);
require('fs').writeFileSync('./style.css.map', JSON.stringify(result.map));

in render callback into src/index.js and using https://sokra.github.io/source-map-visualization/ to look at the generated source map and it has invalid mapping. Tried to use sassOptions.sourceMap: true and sassOptions.outFile: 'style.css' and it broken also.

[alexander-akait]

I was wrong, bug in css-loader (in postcss), I will move it to css-loader, postcss output invalid source maps

[JParkinson1991]

@evilebottnawi given the bug has now been narrowed down to css-loader, i assume we can rule out dart sass being a fix (ie node-sass being the issue)?

[alexander-akait]

@JParkinson1991 not sure, using sass (dart-sass) solve issue, maybe something wrong in mapping for node-sass, it is a real hard bug, I don’t even know where we will need to start

[JParkinson1991]

Yeah it does seem like a tricky bug to track down! Atleast there is some sort of work around in place with using dart sass.

Just for clarity, using dart sass with npm install --save-dev sass is all thats needed? Removing node-sass of course.

I will dig around this soon and verify dart sass can be used as a work around.

[alexander-akait]

Just for clarity, using dart sass with npm install --save-dev sass is all thats needed? Removing node-sass of course.

Yes

I will dig around this soon and verify dart sass can be used as a work around.

I already checked this and everything works fine, I'm not sure that I can find the time to track down this error in the near future

[JParkinson1991]

Just updated the reproducible repository to include dart sass test cases. Everything working as expected.

https://github.com/JParkinson1991/webpack-sourcemaps-debug

[alexander-akait]

Let's close in favor #622, I will add tests to ensure what we fix it after source map improvements